This study analyses company performance by using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to rank the performance of participating companies. The Super Decisions software package was used to compute the rating score. The first stage of this work involved collecting empirical data via questionnaires to characterise the impact of implementing quality and operational methodologies. Next, the AHP was constructed to rank the characteristics in terms of their effectiveness in improving company performance. The research results indicate that companies implementing lean manufacturing and Six Sigma are more effective in improving their financial and operational performance. Additionally, the results reveal that implementing lean manufacturing alone is sufficient to improve innovation performance.